May 2012
Matthews, CE; Kozey-Keadle, S; Sampson, J; Lyden, K; Libertine, A; Bowles, HR; Freedson, PS; Fowke, JH
Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
Previous-day recalls (PDR) can collect detailed information about time spent in specific active and sedentary behaviors, as well as contextual information often missing from other measures. Purpose: Test the validity of a PDR administered by phone against a valid reference measure. Methods. Adolescents (n=91; 12-17 yrs; 53% female) and adults (n=88; 18-71 yrs; 55% female) wore an activPAL (aPAL) for 7 days to measure sedentary (sit/lie) and active time (standing/stepping) and completed up to three PDRs. Interviewers conducted PDRs eliciting open-ended reports of time spent sleeping and in specific active and sedentary behaviors at home, work/school and in the community. Bland- Altman methods and measurement error models evaluated PDR validity versus aPAL on days matched by date and observation time. Results. Adolescents and adults reported 10.0 (SD=2.2) and 9.9 (SD=2.8) hr/d of sedentary time, and 4.2 (SD=1.8) and 5.2 (SD=2.6) hr/d of active time, respectively. Total PDR active and sedentary time was greater than aPAL wear time (difference=0.58 hr/d, p 0.05) negative bias for active time in adolescents (bias=-0.27 (SD=1.37) hr/d) and adults (bias=-0.13 (SD=1.44) hr/d). In contrast, a significant positive bias in PDR sedentary time was evident (p<0.01) in adolescents (bias=0.81 (SD=1.52) hr/d) and adults (bias=0.74 (SD=1.59) hr/d), in part due to greater PDR observation time. Measurement error models indicated: (1) only modest systematic error over the range of sedentary (BQ1=0.90 to 1.00) and active time (BQ1=0.70 to 0.95); (2) random reporting error was greater than systematic reporting error; and (3) correlations between measures were relatively high (Active: rQT=0.54 to 0.73; Sedentary: rQT=0.62 to 80). Reporting error was higher for adolescent females, but similar for adolescent males and all adults. Conclusion. PDRs measuring active and sedentary behaviors can provide useful estimates of population means, can rank-order individuals on the day observed, and systematic reporting errors were low. PDRs may have value in future epidemiological research, particularly for studies testing hypotheses about specific behaviors and the context within which behaviour occurs.
http://content.wkhealth.com/linkback/openurl?sid=WKPTLP:landingpage&an=00005768-201205002-00005
Matthews, CE; Kozey-Keadle, S; Sampson, J; Lyden, K; Libertine, A; Bowles, HR; Freedson, PS; Fowke, JH Abst D-FreeCommPosters : Validation of a Previous Day Recall Measuring Time Spent in Physically Active and Sedentary Behaviors Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 2012. http://content.wkhealth.com/linkback/openurl?sid=WKPTLP:landingpage&an=00005768-201205002-00005.