The Effect of the Environment on the Characteristics of a 30-Minute Brisk Walk

Sellers C, Grant M, Ryan C

16th International WCPT Congress, Amsterdam Netherlands 20 – 23 June 2011. Physiotherapy 97 (S1) : eS1105

Purpose: The aim of the study was to examine the differences between a 30-minute self-timed brisk walk taken in two different environments: park and urban. Relevance: Regular physical activity has a beneficial impact on health, both in terms of preventing disease and improving quality of life. Physical activity guidelines recommend a minimum of 30 accumulated minutes of moderate intensity activity, in ?10 minute blocks, for adults on most days, where moderate intensity is described as the equivalent of brisk walking. As exercise has a dose-response relationship with health benefits, an understanding of the types of environment most likely to elicit higher intensity exercise will enable health professionals to give more effective activity advice. However, little research has investigated the effect of a specific environment on the exercise taking place within it. Participants: A convenience sample of 40 healthy adults took part (16 male, 24 female, mean age 22.9 5.53 years). Methods: A cross-over design was used with participants carrying out both walks on the same day; Test order was randomised. Participants were instructed to walk briskly for 30 minutes at two predefined walk locations in Glasgow, Scotland, while a researcher followed at a distance. An activPAL activity monitor attached to the participant’s thigh recorded duration, exercise intensity (based on cadence) and the number of stops. Analysis: Minitab 15 software was used to perform the data analysis, using a 5% level of significance. Differences in outcome measures between the two walking environments were tested using a 2-tailed paired-t test for normal data, and a Wilcoxon matched pairs test for nonparametric data. Cadence thresholds of ? 96 steps/minute (men) and ? 107 steps/minute (women) were used to identify moderate intensity walking (Tudor-Locke, 2005). Results: All participants achieved a mean cadence above the minimum threshold required for moderate intensity activity for both walks. There was a significant difference in the mean cadence achieved between the two environments (park: 119.11 8.50 steps/minute (mean SD), urban: 110.80 8.95 steps/minute (mean SD), ? < 0.01). There were also significantly more stops during urban walks than park walks (park: median 0 IQR 0, urban: median 4 IQR 3, p < 0.01). Examination of individual walking profiles revealed that participants walked at a similar cadence during both walks, but stopped more frequently during urban walks, resulting in a lower overall mean exercise intensity during urban walks. No differences were found between the durations of the self-timed walks in the two environments. Conclusions: Both urban and park environments supported walking at a moderate or vigorous intensity level, satisfying physical activity recommendations. However, walkers were able to achieve a higher average intensity of exercise in the park due to the lack of interruptions. Implications: A brisk walk in a park may provide a higher intensity of exercise than a brisk walk in an urban environment. Furthermore the physiological effect of interruptions in exercise are unknown and may potentially reduce the benefit of the exercise being taken. Therefore walking in a park environment may provide increased health benefits compared to an urban environment.

NA

Sellers C, Grant M, Ryan C The Effect of the Environment on the Characteristics of a 30-Minute Brisk Walk 16th International WCPT Congress, Amsterdam Netherlands 20 – 23 June 2011. Physiotherapy 97 (S1) : eS1105 2011. http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0031940611000691.