Brauer S, Daniel H, Payne C, Lamont R
ISPGR World Congress, Fort Lauderdale, USA 25 – 29 June 2017; Abstract Book Oral 0.9.4, p 356
BACKGROUND: Despite the known benefits, physical activity (PA) is low in many people with Parkinson’s disease (PD). Achieving and maintaining optimal volume and intensity of physical activity is a challenge. Activity prescription is typically based on that for healthy adults, however energy expenditure during walking may be higher in people with PD due to gait impairments. Commercially-available activity monitors may aid in motivating people to increase PA levels, but it is not clear whether they are accurate in people with PD. The aims were: 1) To investigate the relationship between activity intensity and walking cadence, walking environment and characteristics of PD. 2) To determine the concurrent validity of two commercially-available activity monitors (the Fitbit Charge HR and Garmin V vosmart HR) in people with PD. METHODS: 33 people with mild-moderate PD participated in this cross-sectional study. Participants performed six, two-minute walks along a 44m corridor at their usual walking pace, then at target cadences of 60, 80, 100, 120 and 140 steps/minute. A 500m outdoor walk was also performed. Measures of activity intensity (e.g. oxygen consumption, heart rate) were compared across the seven walking conditions. Step count was recorded by the Garmin and Fitbit devices worn on both wrists, and the ActivPAL3. Spatiotemporal parameters of participant?s normal and fast gait were recorded using the GAITRite. RESULTS: There was a significant increase in oxygen consumption and heart rate for each increase in cadence from 60 to 140 steps/minute. Measures of oxygen consumption and heart rate were significantly higher during outdoor walking. Oxygen consumption when walking outdoors was positively correlated with self-reported activity levels, step length and gait speed. Compared to the ActivPAL3, both commercial activity monitors had low error (1-7%) and moderate to high consistency at self-selected pace both in (ICCs>0.51; p<0.05) and outdoors (ICCs>0.78; p<0.05). The Garmin recorded low error (<5%) and high agreement (ICCs >0.70; p<0.001) for all cadences >80 steps/minute. The Fitbit had high error (>10%) and low consistency for all cadences except 100-120steps/minute. Both recorded high error at 60steps/min. CONCLUSIONS: Cadence can be used to define physical activity intensity in people with PD, regardless of walking location. Participant characteristics associated with oxygen consumption are modifiable, thus could be addressed to reduce energy costs of walking. The Fitbit Charge HR and Garmin v vosmart HR are accurate in counting steps compared to the ActivPAL3 at self-selected walking speed both in and outdoors, but not at low speed. The Garmin v vosmart HR was consistently accurate at reflecting cadence at a variety of gait speeds, whereas the Fitbit Charge HR showed high error. Investigations should be undertaken to confirm the accuracy of commercially available devices prior to use in patient populations.Brauer S, Daniel H, Payne C, Lamont R Accuracy of commercially available activity monitors in people with Parkinson’s disease ISPGR World Congress, Fort Lauderdale, USA 25 – 29 June 2017; Abstract Book Oral 0.9.4, p 356 2017. NA.