Counting Steps in Research: A Comparison of Accelerometry and Pedometry

Oliver, Melody

Open Journal of Preventive Medicine

The objective of this study was to assess the validity of the step count functions in Actical accelerometers and activPAL inclinometers, compared with pe-dometer-derived step count data. Firstly, directly observed step counts over 3 treadmill speeds were compared with steps collected from 3 pedometers, accelerometers, and inclinometers in 10 adults. Secondly, step count data were derived from 22 partici-pants who wore a pedometer, accelerometer, and in-clinometer over 48 hours. Agreement between meas-urement tools was determined. All monitors appro-priately measured steps in the laboratory conditions. In free living conditions, the mean percentage differ-ences with pedometer-determined step counts were –7.3% and 7.0% for the Actical and activPAL monitors, respectively. With the exception of slow walking for the Actical units (ICC < 0.001), acceptable reli-ability was found within units for all treadmill speeds, and across units during the free living condition. The 95% prediction interval ranges were wide, ranging from –68.8% to 54.2% for the Acticals, and from –39.1% to 53.2% for the activPALs. Step counts gathered from Actical and activPAL units should not be used interchangeably with pedometer-derived step count data.

NA

Oliver, Melody Counting Steps in Research: A Comparison of Accelerometry and Pedometry Open Journal of Preventive Medicine 2011. http://www.scirp.org/journal/PaperDownload.aspx?DOI=10.4236/ojpm.2011.11001.