Differences between activPAL and ActiGraph defined sedentary time in Australian preschool children

Janssen, X; Cliff, D; Okely, A; Reilly, J; Jones, R

ISBNPA 2011

To compare estimates of sedentary time using 5 ActiGraph cut-point definitions with estimates from the activPAL in preschool children. Methods 20 children aged 4-6 years (5.1 ± 0.8years) completed a ~110 min whole-room calorimeter protocol involving age-appropriate sedentary behaviours (eg. watching a movie, drawing) and light physical activities (eg. playing with toys, dressing up in costumes). Each child wore an activPAL and an ActiGraph GT3X. Percentage of time spent in sedentary behaviour was calculated for the activPAL and each of the five ActiGraph sedentary behaviour cut-points for young children: <100 counts per minute (cpm); <800cpm (Puyau et al., 2002); <1100cpm (Reilly et al., 2003); <1492cpm (Van Cauwenberghe et al., 2010), and; <1596cpm (Sirard et al., 2005). Differences were tested using dependent t-tests with a Bonferroni adjustment for multiple comparisons (p<0.01). Results activPAL classified 61.3% (±12.0%) of the whole-room calorimeter protocol as sedentary behaviour. ActiGraph estimates were: <100cpm = 62.2% (±12.1%), <800cpm = 83.5% (±7.9%), <1100cpm = 87.9% (±6.7%), <1492cpm = 91.9% (±5.6%) and <1596cpm = 91.4% (±5.8%). Estimates from all ActiGraph cutpoints, with the exception of <100cpm (p=0.694), were significantly different to activPAL estimates (all p<0.001). Conclusion The ActiGraph cut-point of 100cpm provided the most similar classification of sedentary time to the activPAL. Studies using higher sedentary behaviour cut-points for the ActiGraph may overestimate sedentary time in preschoolers, although these findings need to be confirmed in validity studies with a criterion measure of sedentary behaviour.

NA

Janssen, X; Cliff, D; Okely, A; Reilly, J; Jones, R Differences between activPAL and ActiGraph defined sedentary time in Australian preschool children ISBNPA 2011 2011. http://isbnpa.eproceedings.com.au/papers/P207.pdf.