Targeting low physical fitness in older adults with colorectal cancer : a personalized approach to preoperative – Karolinska Institutet

Danielsson, Johanna

Thesis

Low physical fitness is associated with an increased risk of postoperative complications following colorectal cancer surgery. Because physical fitness progressively declines with advancing age, older adults are particularly vulnerable to adverse postoperative outcomes. Preoperative exercise is a promising strategy to improve physical fitness before surgery, but its impact on postoperative outcomes remains uncertain. Heterogeneity in study design and exercise protocols likely contributes to mixed findings in previous trials and limits the guidance available for clinical practice. Additional challenges for older adults undergoing colorectal cancer surgery include low recruitment, poor adherence, and short treatment target timelines in Sweden, where treatment is expected to start within 2-3 weeks from treatment decision. To address these challenges, a home-based, personalized, high-intensity preoperative exercise program, partly supervised by a physiotherapist, was developed for older adults with low physical fitness. A preceding feasibility study indicated high acceptability and adherence to the program. The main aim of this thesis was to evaluate the effect of this intervention on postoperative outcomes.

The thesis is based on a randomized controlled trial (RCT) including adults aged ≥65 years, scheduled for surgery for colorectal cancer or colorectal liver metastases, who demonstrated low physical fitness based on maximal walking speed. Participants were randomized to usual care or preoperative exercise. The intervention consisted of inspiratory muscle training, aerobic exercise, and strength training through both standardized and personalized exercises. The Patient-Specific Functional Scale (PSFS), a scale designed to identify and quantify limitations in meaningful activities, was used for the personalized component. Papers II and III (published papers), used a randomized controlled design, papers I and IV (manuscripts) only included participants allocated to the exercise group.

In paper I, we evaluated content validity, construct validity, and sensitivity to change of the PSFS in 33 participants. The PSFS showed good content validity, with most PSFS-activities mapping to the activity component of the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health. Construct validity was uncertain: correlations between the PSFS and a self-reported measure of mobility was fair to moderate, while no statistically significant correlations were observed with other subjective measures of physical function, independence in activities of daily living, or objective measures of physical fitness. The PSFS appeared sensitive to change, as improvements after exercise were observed. These findings support the PSFS as a potentially valuable tool for evaluating preoperative exercise, although additional methods may be needed to fully assess its underlying construct in this context.

Paper II included 51 participants. Analyses using binary logistic regression did not demonstrate an effect of preoperative exercise on postoperative complications or discharge destination. Furthermore, we could not demonstrate an effect of preoperative exercise on hospital length of stay.

Paper III included 52 participants. We used linear mixed models to analyze the effect of preoperative exercise on inspiratory muscle strength and functional capacity (using the 6-minute walk test), and a non-parametric Friedman rank sum test for lower-extremity functional strength. We found that preoperative exercise improved postoperative inspiratory muscle strength, but not functional capacity or lower-extremity functional strength.

For both paper II and paper III, a small sample size due to recruitment difficulties reduced statistical power which may have influenced the results. It is also possible that the duration of the exercise program was insufficient to lead to meaningful benefits. Although we demonstrated that personalized preoperative exercise can be delivered within short treatment target timeframes, external validity is affected by organizational challenges and a relatively high decline rate.

In paper IV, a qualitative study, interviews with 14 participants were analyzed with content analysis. The overarching theme, motivation in a challenging situation fosters readiness supported by engagement and guidance, reflected the balance between barriers (e.g., a busy preoperative period, cancer-related symptoms and comorbidities) and a strong motivation to exercise. Participants emphasized the importance of physiotherapist support and the convenience of exercising at home. Perceived benefits emerged related to feeling more prepared for surgery and recovery.

Danielsson, Johanna Targeting low physical fitness in older adults with colorectal cancer : a personalized approach to preoperative – Karolinska Institutet 2006. https://openarchive.ki.se/articles/thesis/Targeting_low_physical_fitness_in_older_adults_with_colorectal_cancer_a_personalized_approach_to_preoperative/30196804?file=62825959.