Donnachie C, Hunt K, Wyke S
SPARC Conference 26 October 2016, Edinburgh; Abstracts p 12
Aim/purpose Physical activity (PA) is important for health and wellbeing. Previous research suggests that receiving information on how much PA people are actually doing may influence behaviour change and providing feedback might be another potential tool for increasing PA. But how do people respond to feedback? Does it help or hinder their attempts to change? The aim of this study is to understand men s responses to receiving personalised feedback on changes in their activity levels (measured using an objective PA monitor known as an activPAL3 ) during Football Fans in Training (FFIT), a 12 week, male only group weight loss programme, delivered via Scottish Professional Football League clubs to overweight/obese men, aged 3565 years. Methods 12 football clubs delivered the FFIT programme to 306 men in February-April 2012. At four clubs, a sub-sample of men (n=63), were invited to wear an objective PA device (activPAL3 ) before and after taking part in the 12 week programme; and again at 12 month follow-up, and were offered feedback on their objectively assessed PA. Telephone interviews (n=28) were conducted with participants after taking part in FFIT, sampled to compare the reactions of men who did and did not achieve weight loss during the 12 week programme. Data were analysed thematically and interpreted using a prominent theory of behaviour change (i.e. Self-Determination Theory [SDT]; Deci & Ryan, 2000). Results Men s use of the feedback on their objectively-measured PA depended on whether it was supportive of basic needs which SDT defines as crucial for optimal motivation and wellbeing. These needs are autonomy (the need to feel in control and the originator of one s actions), competence (the need to feel sufficiently challenged and interact effectively in one s environment) and relatedness (the need to feel connected to others and supported in one s pursuits). Men who could interpret the information and were successful in achieving weight loss and behaviour change during the 12 week programme were most positive about feedback. However, men who did not achieve weight loss were unenthusiastic, experiencing feedback as further confirmation of their lack of success. Some men struggled to make sense of the information, perceiving it as too complex. For these men, feedback was not viewed as a useful aid for behaviour change. Discussion These findings imply that greater sensitivity and support may be required when providing personalised information to individuals unable to sufficiently change their lifestyle behaviours during weight management/PA programmes. Further advice and additional tailoring of feedback might be important when providing comprehensive feedback to individuals to ensure optimal understanding and utility of the information. Conclusion Providing personalised feedback on changes in PA within weight management/PA programmes may increase longer term behaviour change for those who are already successful but undermine motivation for those who are not. To be useful the information must be presented simply.Donnachie C, Hunt K, Wyke S It was like opening up your exam results and saying, Hey, I did alright here! : men s accounts of receiving information on objectively assessed physical activity. Evidence from Football Fans in Training (FFIT) SPARC Conference 26 October 2016, Edinburgh; Abstracts p 12 2016. NA.