Powell C, Donnelly A, Lyons M, Anderson R
4th ICAMPAM, 10 – 12 June 2015, Limerick; PS1.7
Introduction The Global Positioning System (GPS) is a satellite-based system that provides location information on the earth’s surface. This study examined the distance measurement accuracy for three GPS devices and also the reliability and validity of said devices for positional measurement. Methods A Garmin Forerunner 110, an iPhone 4s and a VXSport Log330a were selected. Ten participants completed a surveyor measured 2.54km route at a self-selected pace while wearing the devices. A researcher also completed the route eight times. Based on previous work1 the route included seven surveyed coordinates where participants stopped for 20 seconds to create time points. An activPAL3 was worn to determine when a participant was stationary or in motion. Eighteen trials were included in the analysis. GPS measured distance was compared to the known distance. The Haversine formula2 and 95% confidence interval ellipses were used to examine positional accuracy. Data from the Garmin was excluded from the positional accuracy analysis due to its sampling methodology. Results The mean difference between the known distance and the GPS measured distances were 84.44m (3.3%) (VX), 234.44m (9.23%) (Garmin) and 470.65m (18.53%) (iPhone) (Table 1). The mean difference between the known coordinates and the mean of the collected coordinates were 8.02m (iPhone) and 8.11m (VX). The mean areas of the 95% confidence interval ellipses were 63.85m2 (iPhone) and 86.28m2 (VX). Discussion Numerous factors have an influence on GPS device accuracy (e.g. environmental conditions, device location). Depending on device selection, there can be as little as 3% error when measuring overall distance. Large variations in positional accuracy were observed despite the number and spread of satellites falling within recommended levels for each trial2. The large distances from known coordinates may make these GPS devices unsuitable for research where greater positional accuracy is required. See pdf for Table 1.Powell C, Donnelly A, Lyons M, Anderson R An examination of the accuracy and reliability of three GPS devices 4th ICAMPAM, 10 – 12 June 2015, Limerick; PS1.7 2015. http://ulir.ul.ie/handle/10344/4487.