Laboratory Validation of Two Activity Monitors for Measuring Time in Sitting, Standing, and Walking

Abraham TL, McClain J, Pettee K, Tudor-Locke C

ACSM annual meeting, New Orleans 2007 May. Med Sci Sport Exer 2007 May; 39 (5) : S184 – S185

While there has been much research on measuring physical activity, there has been little focused on objective measurement of duration and frequency of sedentary behaviors (i.e., sitting/standing) and lower intensity walking behaviors. Within the population, prolonged bouts of sitting may be associated with obesity-related outcomes, independent of participation in moderate to vigorous physical activity. PURPOSE: The purpose of this laboratory-based study was to determine if the Intelligent Device for Energy Expenditure and Physical Activity (IDEEA; MiniSun, Fresno, CA) and the ActivPal Professional (Pal; PAL Technologies LTD, Glasgow, United Kingdom) are valid measures of time spent in sitting, standing and walking behaviors compared to a direct observation criterion. METHODS: Participants (n=10, male=5 and female=5; 30.6 7.0 years) wore both monitors concurrently while performing 5 minutes bouts each of sitting, standing and walking on a treadmill at 1.5 mph and 2.5 mph. Participants were videotaped as a record of directly observed (DO) behavior. Due to measurement properties of these monitors, data collected during the first and the fifth minute of each bout were dropped from the analysis, leaving 3 minutes (i.e., 180 seconds) of data for each bout. Data were downloaded as per manufacturer recommendations. Time in each behavior was compared by difference scores and ANOVA across instruments using observed time as the criterion standard. RESULTS: Both instruments showed complete agreement (i.e., 0 difference scores) with DO of sitting, standing, and walking at 2.5mph. The Pal also showed complete agreement with DO walking at 1.5mph whereas the IDEEA detected 159 43 seconds of 180 seconds observed. Post-hoc analysis revealed that the IDEEA occasionally misclassified walking at 1.5mph as standing. However, IDEEA mean time spend walking 1.5mph was not significantly different from Pal or DO. CONCLUSIONS: Both monitors provide valid laboratory measures of time spent in sitting, standing and low intensity walking behaviors. Valid measures of these behaviors are required prior to conducting larger scale field studies necessary to better understand the role of sedentary behaviors in health.

NA

Abraham TL, McClain J, Pettee K, Tudor-Locke C Laboratory Validation of Two Activity Monitors for Measuring Time in Sitting, Standing, and Walking ACSM annual meeting, New Orleans 2007 May. Med Sci Sport Exer 2007 May; 39 (5) : S184 – S185 2007. http://journals.lww.com/acsm-msse/pages/results.aspx?k=Abraham&Scope=ThisIssue&txtKeywords=Abraham&ThisIssue=http://journals.na.lww.com/content/acsm-msse/2007/05001.